
Some have responded, and the first one to read it, Jim Heskett, who's published a book of poetry recently, Love Poems, Hate Poems, was the first to come back to me. I gave him a list of questions that I thought he might like to answer, and here are the unadulterated responses.
Me: Did the book entertain you, keep you wanting to know what
happened next?
Jim: It did. The first chapter had a nice mystery hook with the
blood-taking barber. The suspense had a nice ramp-up over the first half of the
book.
Me: Did the characters come across as real people for you?
Jim: Hard to gauge, since I’m not too familiar with children’s
literature. It felt like a fairy tale, a bit like Neil Gaiman.
Me: Were any of the lines or situations amusing to you?
Jim: The banter between Olivia and Billy was pretty clever.
Me: Did you find the situations plausible, given that there’s an
element of fantasy in it?
Jim: I did, but it seemed odd to me that Jerry wouldn’t recognize
his own parents after only twenty years. Also, that Billy thought of his dad as
“jerry” and not “dad.”
Me: Did you feel that the language was at a suitable level for
younger readers (given that it’s intended for kids from 6 - 12, roughly)
Jim: I think so, it seemed comparable to the first couple Harry
Potter books.
Me: Did you enjoy it as an adult reader? Would you read it to
your kids? (Well, when he’s ready...)
Jim: I did enjoy it! Good suspense, fun situations, and a
satisfying ending.
Me: Did you find there were any cultural differences that you
queried while reading it?
Jim: A little, but I lived in Australia, so I was able to puzzle
out most of the slight language differences. Referring to the skateboarders as
Ninjas was a new one to me.
Me: This is intended to be a stand-alone story, but it has links
back to the first book in the series. Did it make you want to find out what the
first book was about?
Jim: Since I knew nothing about the first book, I didn’t know
what any of those links back to the first book were. Maybe adding some mystery
by making vague references to things that happened before might help.
Me: Was there anything that really irritated you...?
Jim: I found some POV problems that stuck out to me… the POV
seemed mostly in Billy’s head, but occasionally it would jump into another
person’s head for a few sentences here and there. That’s a small quibble but
those things always pull me out of the story.
No comments:
Post a Comment