Remember back in the dim, distant past when consumption almost always meant someone had tuberculosis? If you were in a novel, or a stage play, and were dying of consumption, you were automatically offered an extra dose of romance, because for some reason there was something peculiarly romantic about consumptives: think of Mimi, in La Boheme, or Violetta in La Traviata. Dostoevsky has several consumptive character in his novels, but Dickens managed to limit himself to just one: Smike, in Nicholas Nickleby. Thomas Mann goes to opposite extreme, and in The Magic Mountain includes an entire cast of consumptives - admittedly the book is set in a sanatorium. One of Anne of Green Gables' friends dies of 'the galloping consumption' (as opposed, I suppose, to the dawdling version).
Consumption/tuberculosis continues to fascinate more recent writers and creators: Ingrid Bergman died of consumption in The Bells of St Mary's (isn't that an unnecessary apostrophe there? - shouldn't the title have been the less alliterative, The Bells of St Mary?) as did Nicole Kidman in Moulin Rouge - at the end of her biggest performance. Fictional consumptives achieve all sorts of last minute heroics. Even in anime and manga, you'll find a variety of consumptive characters. Plainly Japan has a bit of a thing about the disease.
But tuberculosis, as it's more generally known these days, is barely visible in the Western world. Large sanatoriums have been turned into all sorts of non-medical establishments. And those awful outside verandahs have been closed in, hopefully. It was normal to put TB patients out in the fresh air for their health - even letting them sleep out in the open air (though under the verandah roof). I suspect more than a few TB patients died of pneumonia rather than TB.
Mike Crowl is the world's leading authority on his own opinions on art, music, movies, and writing.
Pages
- Home
- About Mike Crowl and his books
- Columns from Column 8
- Music I have writ
- One Easter Evening
- When Dad went Fishing
- The Night the Wind Blew the Roof Off
- Plays and Productions since 2004
- The Disenchanted Wizard - the original opening chapters
- Mike Crowl's Scribble Pad
- Taonga columns by the Juggling Bookie
Showing posts with label mann. Show all posts
Showing posts with label mann. Show all posts
Wednesday, August 14, 2013
Consumption
Labels:
anime,
consumption,
dickens,
dostoevsky,
manga,
mann,
movies,
novels,
sanatoriums,
tb,
tuberculosis
Thursday, December 22, 2011
Rev Helene Mann
Rev Helene Mann, who died unexpectedly two days ago in Dunedin Hospital, always announced herself, when she came into the shop I managed (OC Books), as 'your favourite customer'. And in many ways she was. From a purely retail point of view, she could be guaranteed to buy at least one book on each visit, but would more likely buy several. But it wasn't just her book-buying that made her visits interesting: it was her conversation. Invariably we would discuss something of interest: books, theology, Celtic Christianity (one of her favourite subjects and one she studied, and one she introduced me to), her enthusiasm for Pelagius, Anglicanism and a host of other subjects.
Like many of my customers, she became a friend. We'd meet on the street and talk, or meet at a conference and talk. It was never just a case of retailer and customer, but much more. She was one of the many people I missed when I left the shop, although we occasionally had a chance meeting afterwards, including just the other day when my wife and I met her in South Dunedin. She didn't look well (and hadn't done for some time), but was still bustling her way forward, trying to keep up with the many tasks she took on.
She was short, but made up for it in seemingly boundless energy, even when her health knocked her back. She was intellectually sharp, and though we crossed swords very occasionally, in general our relationship was one of humour and the enjoyment of catching up again. I will miss seeing her - as I'm sure hundreds of others will. May she rest in the peace of her Creator, and enjoy His company eternally.
PS - 14.1.12
Just been informed by Jim Mann, Helene's husband, that he read this post after his relatives in Wales informed him of it (!) Such is the nature of the Internet.
Like many of my customers, she became a friend. We'd meet on the street and talk, or meet at a conference and talk. It was never just a case of retailer and customer, but much more. She was one of the many people I missed when I left the shop, although we occasionally had a chance meeting afterwards, including just the other day when my wife and I met her in South Dunedin. She didn't look well (and hadn't done for some time), but was still bustling her way forward, trying to keep up with the many tasks she took on.
She was short, but made up for it in seemingly boundless energy, even when her health knocked her back. She was intellectually sharp, and though we crossed swords very occasionally, in general our relationship was one of humour and the enjoyment of catching up again. I will miss seeing her - as I'm sure hundreds of others will. May she rest in the peace of her Creator, and enjoy His company eternally.
PS - 14.1.12
Just been informed by Jim Mann, Helene's husband, that he read this post after his relatives in Wales informed him of it (!) Such is the nature of the Internet.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)